The Surgeon Everyone Wants to Work With
October 7, 2026
Author: Smruti K. Patel, MD FAANS FACS FCNS FAAP
Every surgeon remembers them.
The attending whose operating room felt calm even during chaos. The surgeon whose team was fully engaged. The leader whose nurses, residents, anesthesiologists, and colleagues genuinely looked forward to working with them.
Their technical skill may have been exceptional but that wasn’t what made them memorable.
What set them apart was how they made others feel.
In medicine, we spend years developing our technical abilities. We learn anatomy, master procedures, and refine our clinical judgment. Yet, as our careers progress, it becomes increasingly clear that technical excellence alone is not what defines the most effective surgeons.
The surgeons who have the greatest impact are often the ones who build trust, inspire confidence, communicate clearly, and create environments where teams can thrive.
In other words, they become the surgeons everyone wants to work with.
Technical Excellence Is Expected
Patients deserve technical mastery. Colleagues expect competence. Surgical training is built around developing expertise.
But technical skill is the entry ticket, not the differentiator.
Every department has technically gifted surgeons. Yet some consistently attract strong teams, exceptional trainees, and loyal collaborators.
Why?
Because people choose to work with leaders who make them better.
The surgeon everyone wants to work with understands that surgery is fundamentally a team sport. No operation succeeds because of one person alone. Every outcome reflects the performance of an entire system of people working together under pressure.
They Make It Safe to Speak Up
One of the most important qualities of an effective surgeon is creating psychological safety.
In healthcare, silence can be dangerous.
The circulating nurse who notices a discrepancy.
The resident who sees something unexpected.
The anesthesiologist who has a concern.
The junior team member who feels uncertain.
The best surgeons create an environment where every member of the team feels comfortable speaking up.
They ask questions.
They invite input.
They listen.
Most importantly, they respond respectfully when concerns are raised.
Psychological safety is not about being agreeable. It is about creating a culture where patient safety always outweighs hierarchy.
The surgeon everyone wants to work with understands that a team willing to speak up is a team that protects patients.
They Stay Calm When Things Go Wrong
Every surgeon eventually encounters crisis.
Unexpected bleeding.
Difficult anatomy.
Equipment failure.
A rapidly deteriorating patient.
In these moments, leadership becomes particularly visible.
Teams take emotional cues from their leader. When the surgeon becomes reactive, frustrated, or overwhelmed, the entire room feels it.
Conversely, when the surgeon remains calm, focused, and deliberate, the team gains confidence.
One of the most important leadership lessons in surgery is this:
In moments of crisis, the room borrows the emotional stability of the surgeon.
The surgeons everyone wants to work with are not necessarily the ones who never encounter problems. They are the ones who lead effectively when problems arise.
They Respect Everyone in the Room
The operating room contains individuals with different levels of expertise, experiences, and responsibilities.
The strongest leaders recognize that respect is not something reserved for peers or superiors.
It extends to everyone.
The scrub technician who anticipates needs.
The nurse who catches an error.
The resident learning a new skill.
The anesthesiologist managing a challenging airway.
Respect builds trust.
Trust builds communication.
Communication improves outcomes.
The surgeon everyone wants to work with understands that every member of the team contributes to success.
They Teach While They Lead
Great surgeons do more than perform operations.
They develop people.
Trainees remember the surgeons who challenged them while preserving their confidence. Teams remember leaders who invested in their growth rather than simply directing tasks.
Teaching is not limited to residents. Every interaction in the operating room creates an opportunity to coach, mentor, and elevate those around us.
The most influential surgeons leave behind more than a case log, an innovation, or an instrument named after them.
They leave behind stronger surgeons, stronger nurses, and stronger teams.
They Understand That Culture Matters
Culture is often described as “how we do things around here.”
In surgery, culture influences everything.
It determines whether concerns are voiced or ignored.
Whether mistakes become learning opportunities or sources of shame.
Whether teams feel energized or exhausted.
The surgeon everyone wants to work with understands that culture is created one interaction at a time.
It is shaped by how we respond under stress.
How we communicate during conflict.
How we treat people when no one is watching.
Leadership is NOT an occasional act. It is a daily practice.
A New Definition of Surgical Excellence
For decades, surgery celebrated technical prowess above all else.
Today, our understanding of excellence is evolving.
The most effective surgeons are technically outstanding, but they are also emotionally intelligent, collaborative, and self-aware.
They command respect without demanding it.
They create accountability without creating fear.
They lead without diminishing others.
Women in surgery have helped challenge the traditional archetype of the surgical leader, demonstrating that empathy, emotional intelligence, collaboration, and psychological safety are not ‘soft’ leadership skills—they are the qualities that make people want to follow you and teams want to work with you.
Not by changing the expectations of excellence, but by expanding them.
Because at the end of a career, people may not remember every operation you performed, the papers you wrote, or the awards you won.
But they will remember how you made them feel.
They will remember whether they learned from you, trusted you, and grew because of you.
And perhaps the highest compliment a surgeon can receive is not that they were the most technically gifted person in the department.
It is that they were the surgeon everyone wanted to work with.
This article draws on work by Amy Edmondson on psychological safety, Atul Gawande’s writings on surgical systems and teamwork, TeamSTEPPS patient safety research, and contemporary studies on operating room communication, leadership, and team performance.

Dr. Patel is a board-certified pediatric neurosurgeon at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center and Associate Professor of Neurosurgery at the University of Cincinnati College of Medicine. She serves as the Associate Program Director of the University of Cincinnati Department of Neurosurgery Residency Program and Associate Fellowship Director for Pediatric Neurosurgery. She completed her medical school education at Rutgers, New Jersey Medical School, neurosurgery residency at the University of Cincinnati Medical Center, and her pediatric neurosurgery fellowship at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center. Her main clinical interests include pediatric brain tumor and skull base surgery, longitudinal care for patients with spina bifida from in utero to transition to adulthood, and neurosurgical tone management for cerebral palsy and other related disorders. Across her roles as a surgeon, educator, program builder, and mentor, Dr. Patel has sought to model a form of surgical leadership grounded not only in excellence and accountability, but in trust, collaboration, mentorship, and creating teams that people genuinely want to be part of.